logo

We Naturally Regress to our Dominant Leadership Style!

Knowledge Center

Situational Leadership

Forum

Rating

James L Mileur
15
James L Mileur
Career Consultant, United States

We Naturally Regress to our Dominant Leadership Style!

It may be "... just a trivial fact of life that leaders have to behave differently in different situations".
But another "trivial" fact is that we "naturally" regress to our dominant style without constant vigilance to treat every situation as a unique encounter that will not be served by a "one size fits all" method.

X

Sign up for free

Welcome to the Situational Leadership forum of 12manage.

Here we exchange knowledge and experiences in the field of Situational Leadership.

❗Sign up now to gain access to 12manage. Completely free.

Reg
 

Rating

  SATISH PANDE
3
SATISH PANDE
Business Consultant, India
 

Leadership Style Should Conform to Individual's (leader's) Personality

I believe a manager cannot switch on and off different leadership styles in different situations because he has a unique personality. If he tries contrasting styles, people will not take him seriously and he will be only an actor doing a role.
A leader has to lead his team, empowering and guiding them and not interfering. He needs to use a combination of styles which conforms to his personality.
Mintzberg's example of a conductor of an orchestra ("Covert Leadership") is the best example. Such a leader controls, coordinates, balances and also empowers his teammates, highlighting the performance of good, hiding the not so good and silencing those who are not up to the mark."
A person performing the role of a leader must absorb the meaning of all styles, he would automatically, reflexively react in the appropriate manner if his intentions are fair and true.

  Akshat Kumar
2
Akshat Kumar
HR Consultant, India
 

Different Strokes to Different Folks

On the other hand, having fair and true intentions is not enough.
You should speak to different folks in the language they understand and not necessarily in your mother tongue.
Similarly, if you want to take out the best performance from your team, adapt a leadership style that meets their need.

  Jaap de Jonge
1
Jaap de Jonge
Editor, Netherlands
 

Avoiding the Tendency to Use a Dominant Leadership Style

The tendency to fall back to a default or dominant leadership style that worked well in the past, or that a manager/leader is familiar with, is particularly strong when the stakes are high, like when facing a crisis or a major new opportunity.
You can determine what is your default style or stance and prepare for at least considering alternate ones in circumstances like that by using the 4 stances tool by Noble and Kaufman:
LEAN IN - Deciding, directing, guiding, challenging, confronting.
LEAN BACK - Collecting data, analyzing, asking questions, delaying decisions.
LEAN WITH - Empathizing, coaching, collaborating, encouraging.
DON'T LEAN - Contemplating, being still, visualizing, breathing.
Reference: Noble D. and Kaufman C., "The Power of Options", HBR Jan/Feb 2023 pp. 108-115.

 

Leave a comment
Help improve this subject


More on Situational Leadership
Summary Discussion Topics
topic Commitment in Situational Leadership
topic Preferred Management Style for Professionals?
topic Is Situational Leadership Innate in Good Managers?
topic Situational Leadership Activities and Games
topic Criticism of Situational Leadership Model
topic Definition of Job Maturity and Psychological Maturity in SLT
topic Little Research to Backup Situational Leadership
👀We Naturally Regress to our Dominant Leadership Style!
topic Situational Followership
topic In Situational Leadership, the Leader Determines the Situation
topic Is Situational Leadership Depending on Generation of Followers?
topic Practical Situational Leadership Examples
topic Situational Leadership & Performance Rating
topic Leadership Style for a New Institution
🔥 Use of Situational Leadership by Teachers
topic Preferred TEAM Management Style?
Special Interest Group


More on Situational Leadership
Summary Discussion Topics
topic Commitment in Situational Leadership
topic Preferred Management Style for Professionals?
topic Is Situational Leadership Innate in Good Managers?
topic Situational Leadership Activities and Games
topic Criticism of Situational Leadership Model
topic Definition of Job Maturity and Psychological Maturity in SLT
topic Little Research to Backup Situational Leadership
👀We Naturally Regress to our Dominant Leadership Style!
topic Situational Followership
topic In Situational Leadership, the Leader Determines the Situation
topic Is Situational Leadership Depending on Generation of Followers?
topic Practical Situational Leadership Examples
topic Situational Leadership & Performance Rating
topic Leadership Style for a New Institution
🔥 Use of Situational Leadership by Teachers
topic Preferred TEAM Management Style?
Special Interest Group
Knowledge Center

Situational Leadership



About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
© 2024 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V17.2 - Last updated: 20-5-2024. All names ™ of their owners.