Vertical Integration

Knowledge Center

What is Vertical Integration?

Vertical Integration is an approach for increasing or decreasing the level of control which a firm has over its inputs and distribution of outputs.

Vertical integration is the extent to which an organization controls its inputs and the distribution of its products and services. There are two sorts of vertical integration: backward integration and forward integration. A firm’s control of its inputs or supplies is known as: backward integration. A firm’s control of its distribution is known as: forward integration.

Vertical integration is best understood by applying Michael Porter’s Value Chain model. Vertical integration refers to the degree of integration between a firm’s value chain and the value chains of its suppliers and distributors.

Full vertical integration occurs when a firm incorporates the value-chain of a supplier and/or that of a distribution channel into its own value chain. This generally happens either by a firm’s acquiring a supplier and/or a distributor or by a firm’s expanding its operations. Expanding operations means to perform activities traditionally undertaken by suppliers or distributors. A lower degree of vertical integration is commonly known as: Supply Chain Optimization or also as: Supply Chain Planning. This occurs when logistical information is exchanged between a firm and its suppliers and customers. See: Vendor Managed Inventory.

An illustration of vertical integration may be found in the airline industry. By performing the traditional role of travel agents, Airlines have achieved forward integration. Likewise, by performing the role of suppliers such as aircraft maintenance and in-flight catering, airlines have backwards integrated. Similarly, oil refining companies have traditionally owned their oil distribution channels such as gas stations. Sometimes they moved into oil exploration and exploitation..
 

Origin of Vertical Integration. History

The strategic reasons for opting for a vertical integration strategy have changed over the years. During the 19th century, firms used vertical integration to achieve economies of scale. During the middle of the 20th century, vertical integration was used to assure a steady supply of vital inputs. In some cases, the theory of transaction cost economics was applied to backward integration or forward integration, as a means to total cost reduction. That is, it was cheaper for a firm to perform the role of suppliers and distributors than to spend time and money to interact with such parties.

Subsequently, in the late 20th century, competition intensified in most industries. Corporate restructuring resulted in vertical disintegration by reducing the levels of vertical integration in large corporations.

Vertical disintegration is facilitated by the widespread use of information and telecommunications technologies, which support lower transaction costs between market participants. As lower transaction costs can be achieved using information and communication technologies, rather than by vertically integrating, firms start to vertically disintegrate. This effect is commonly known as “Coase’s Law” (in recognition of Ronald Coase's Nobel price) or the “Law of Diminishing Firms”. This law states that when the transaction costs are decreasing, the size of the firm will also decrease.

Usage of Vertical Integration. Applications

Decisions on vertical integration are usually made in the following contexts:

• In the strategy development process, vertical integration may be considered as a strategic choice. For example if suppliers are very powerful, a solution to that threat is to buy a number of them up.
• When you are analyzing industry dynamics, using Porter’s Five Forces model, vertical integration is an action to decrease the bargaining power of suppliers and customers. Compare: Kraljic Model.
• Vertical integration may be a path for reducing transaction costs.

Steps in Vertical Integration. Process

When you are deciding whether to vertically integrate, and to what extent, you should consider the following issues:

1. Are there economies of scope, which would make it cheaper for a firm to control inputs and outputs?
2. Are there any market external factors, which would make it more efficient for a firm to control inputs and outputs?
3. Is there a need to pursue monopoly power?

Strengths of Vertical Integration. Benefits

• Economies of scale.
• Economies of scope.
• Cost reduction.
• Competitiveness.
• Reduce threat from powerful suppliers and/or customers.
• Higher degree of control over the entire value chain.

Limitations of Vertical Integration. Disadvantages

• There is no such thing as a completely integrated or a completely non-integrated firm. Thus the issue is not a choice between these two polar alternatives. Rather, it is a matter of selecting the optimal degree of vertical integration.
• The degree of vertical integration can hardly be determined via quantitative means.
• Whilst Vertical Integration may solve one headache, the firm may well be acquiring a bunch of others. Compare Core Competence.
• Load and capacity balancing between the old and the new activities may be hard to achieve.

Assumptions of Vertical Integration. Conditions

• A firm has to have the competences to undertake an expanded role in the supply chain.

Book: Kathryn Rudie Harrigan - Vertical Integration, Outsourcing, and Corporate Strategy

Book: Roger Blair and David Kaserman - Law and Economics of Vertical Integration and Control

Forum Forum discussions about Vertical Integration. Examples and Case Studies of Vertical Integration Who can share and explain an example of vertical integration? Thanks...... 7   2 comments Symbiotic Resource Interdependencies What is the relationship between vertical integration and the reduction of symbiotic resource interdependencies in the retail industry?... 6   🔥 Food Security in Food Distribution What is implied by: food security? When we talk about "food security" it is usually in the context outlined by the United Nations that people of every nation regardless of who they are should have ph... 5   2 comments Orthogonal Integration Besides horizontal and vertical integration strategies, a third one is orthogonal integration. This would involve a third dimension, in which orthogonal (Editor: ~independent, non-overlapping) partner... 5   (Legal) Limits to Vertical Integration - I would like to mention that backwards vertical integration (take control of supplier) is not legal if you gain control over competitors who source from the same supplier. - The same holds for forw... 5   Vertical Integration Cum Diversification If vertical integration is associated with necessary unrelated diversification, then how to analyze the "fit" and benefits. For ex. An oil refiner & mktg company forays into ethanol business as a part... 5   Flexible Integration Strategy We can approach both horizontal and vertical integration strategy also from the viewpoint of required flexibility. Consider that our business climate and our negotiating capabilities keep changing al... 4   Advantages of Vertical Integration Are there besides the benefits mentioned above still more advantages of vertical integration? Why?... 4   Disadvantages of Vertical Integration Are there besides the limitations mentioned above still more disadvantages of vertical integration? Why?... 4   1 comments Alternatives of Vertical Integration? Hi, given those mentioned limitations, what are the alternative options, other than going for vertical integration? Thanks for your inputs...... 3   Captive Distribution What is the difference between Vertical Distribution (VI) and Captive Distribution (CD)? What is the single most important factor in deciding to adopt a captive strategy? Product? Market conditions?... 1   Quasi Vertical Integration Hi, I would like to know, is quasi-vertical integration the same as vertical integration? If there is a difference, what is it?... 0   2 comments Start a new topic about Vertical Integration Sign up for free

Courses about Vertical Integration. Beginners Course Advanced Course Course for Experts

Best Practices The best, top-rated topics about Vertical Integration. Here you will find the most valuable ideas and practical suggestions. 🥇 Integration Strategy Here's my summary of integration strategies:1. VERTICAL INTEGRATION:1A. Forward (Vertical) integration:= Seeking ownership or increased control over distributors or retailers.Forward integrati... 31   15 comments

Expert Tips Advanced insights about Vertical Integration. Here you will find professional advices by experts. Consultancy Tips Teaching Tips Practical Implementation Tips Two More Forms of Strategic Integration Strategy, Corporate Integration In academic literature there is a mention of at least two more types of developing strategy considered a midddle way bet... Virtual Integration Dell’s Direct Model Case Virtual Integration provides economic benefits of two very different business models: it offers the advantages of a tigh... Vertically Integrated Enterprise Identifying Potential Synergy Areas There are various approached to optimizing structures and processes in a vertically integrated enterprise. This one foll...

Information Sources Various sources of information regarding Vertical Integration. Here you will find powerpoints, videos, news, etc. to use in your own lectures and workshops. Vertical Integration and Horizontal Integration Difference Between Vertical Integration and Horizontal Integration Simple explanation of the essence of the 2 main models for corporate expansion (vertical and horizontal integration) by ... The Make or Buy Decision Vertical Integration Should a firm make its own inputs, buy them on the spot market, or maintain an ongoing relationship with a particular su... Integrating Forward: Meeting Demand and Managing Customers Internet Economy, CRM, Digital Economy, Demand Management, Forward Integration This presentation provides insight into how to meet customer demand and manage customer relationship in the internet era... Trans. Costs & Techn. Adoption VMI, Insurance Industry Advances in frontier technology are only the first in a series of steps that lead to economic growth. The next step invo... Strategic Transfer Pricing, Absorption Costing and Vertical Integration Transfer Pricing, Absorption Costing, Vertical Integration This paper by Robert F. Göx analyzes the use of transfer pricing as a strategic device in divisionalized firms facing du...

Tools Useful tools regarding Vertical Integration. News Videos Presentations   Books Academic More

Compare with Vertical Integration: Horizontal Integration  |  Value Chain  |  Porter Five Forces  |  Core Competence  |  Outsourcing  |  Insourcing  |  Co-opetition  |  Vendor Managed Inventory  |  Supply Chain Planning

Return to Management Hub: Finance & Investing  |  Strategy & Innovation  |  Supply Chain & Quality

More Management Methods, Models and Theory