Plausibility Theory

Knowledge Center

According to Collins & Michalski, "something is plausible if it is conceptually supported by prior knowledge". The Plausibility Theory of Wolfgang Spohn (1985-), Collins & Michalski (reasoning, 1989), Lemaire & Fayol (arithmetic problem solving, 1995), Connell & Keane (cognitive model of plausibility, 2002) provides new insights into decision-making with risks that can't be known. Plausibility is an ineluctable phenomenon of everyday life and ubiquitous. However, it was ignored in cognitive science for a long time, and treated only as an operational variable, rather than being explained or studied in itself.

Bayesian statistics

Until the arrival of the plausibility theory, the common theory which was used by scientists to explain and predict decision-making, was Bayesian statistics. Named for Thomas Bayes, an 18th-century English minister. Bayes developed rules for weighing the likelihood of different events and their expected outcomes. Bayesian statistics were popularized in the 1960s by Howard Raiffa for usage in business environments. According to Bayesian theory, managers make decisions, and managers should make decisions, based on a calculation of the probabilities of all the possible outcomes of a situation. By weighing the value of each outcome by the probability and summing the totals, Bayesian decision makers calculate "expected values" for a decision that must be taken. If the expected value is positive, then the decision should be accepted; if it is negative, it should be avoided.

Limitations of Bayesian statistics

At first sight, this may seem like an orderly working method. However unfortunately, the Bayesian way of explaining decisions faces at least two phenomena that are difficult to explain:

1. The appreciation of downside risk. People normally take a gamble at a 50% chance to earn $10 when they have to pay $5 if they have bad luck. But why generally they refuse to take the same gamble at a 50% chance if they can win $1.000.000 versus a potential loss of $500.000?
2. How to deal with risks that can't be known. These kind of risks, that do not involve predictable odds, are typical for business situations!  Why do managers prefer risks that are known, over risks that can not be known?

Plausibility Theory

Both of these phenomena can be dealt with if the Bayesian calculation of "Expected Value" is replaced by the "Risk Threshold" of the Plausibility Theory. Like its predecessor, the Plausibility Theory assesses the range of possible outcomes, but focuses on the probability of hitting a threshold point - such as a net loss - relative to an acceptable risk. For example: a normally profitable decision is rejected if there is a higher than 2% risk of making a (major) loss. Clearly, plausibility can resolve both weaknesses of Bayesian thinking: the tendency of managers to avoid unacceptable downside risks, and the tendency of managers to avoid taking risks that can't be known.

Typical examples of the application of plausibility theory are the new Basel II rules for capital allocation in the financial services industry.

Forum Forum discussions about Plausibility Theory. 🔥 Plausibility Theory and Taleb See also the more recent work of Nassim Taleb (Black Swan theory). According to Taleb, we currently live in a world of opacity, where knowledge is overestimated and chance and uncertainty are underest... 15   Start a new topic about Plausibility Theory Sign up for free

Courses about Plausibility Theory. Beginners Course Advanced Course Course for Experts

Expert Tips Advanced insights about Plausibility Theory. Here you will find professional advices by experts. Consultancy Tips Teaching Tips Practical Implementation Tips Pitfalls of Traditional Risk Analysis Risk Management, Crisis Management In their 2000 book "Managing Crises Before they happens" Mitroff and Anagnos explain their critics on traditional risks... Plausibility of Consumer Behavior Consumer Decision-making, Marketing Prospect theory, a descriptive model of how people make choices, finds that utility is a function of gains and losses, a... Why Society is More Risky than Before Understanding New Risk Categories, Risk Management In his 1992 book "Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity”, Ulrich Beck describes new risk scenarios that companies have t...

Information Sources Various sources of information regarding Plausibility Theory. Here you will find powerpoints, videos, news, etc. to use in your own lectures and workshops. How to Improve Strategic Decision Making? Strategic Decision Making, Cognitive Bias, M&A, Corporate Finance In this video Michael Mauboussin, Credit Suisse's Head of Financial Strategies, briefly explains parts of Philip E. Tetl... The Six Basic Questions of Risk Management: Introduction to Risk Management Initial Understanding of Risk Management, Risk Management Introduction Managing risk is essentially a process of asking and answering six relatively easy questions no matter what setting (per...

Tools Useful tools regarding Plausibility Theory. News Videos Presentations   Books Academic More

Compare with Plausibility Theory:  Real Options  |  Chaos Theory  |  Strategic Risk Management  |  Credit Risk Management  |  Scenario Planning  |  Analogical Strategic Reasoning  |  Root Cause Analysis  |  CAPM  |  Dialectical Inquiry  |  Theory of Constraints  |  Pyramid Principle

Return to Management Hub: Decision-making & Valuation  |  Finance & Investing  |  Knowledge & Intangibles  |  Program & Project Management  |  Strategy & Innovation

More Management Methods, Models and Theory